An Alaskan journalist's perspective on local and national issues

There was a video that was posted on YouTube by a channel called ForaTV.  They are pretty good about posting some thoughtful videos.  Whether you agree with them or not, they are quite thoughtful.  A very recent video had the former governor of Michigan, and the host of Current TV’s “The War Room,” Jennifer Granholm talking about health care in America.

It’s not a mystery that America spends more money on healthcare.  The amount rounds out to roughly $8,000 per person.  This would be perfectly fine, if what we were getting for our money was worth what we spent.  This, however, is not the case.  Approximately 45,000 people die every year from a lack of health insurance, according to a study from Harvard University.  Over 50 million people in America don’t have health insurance.  One of the biggest causes of bankruptcy is health care costs.  These are real problems that are completely verifiable.

However, take a look at the video linked at the top.  After watching it, take a look down in the comments section.  You’ll find lovely little gems like this –

this women is horrible. i dont spend anywhere near 10000 per year. why should me and my family who have our own problems be paying for others? gottt damn.

truth! i’m sick of government punishing me with absurd taxes because i’m responsible enough to live healthy and save

i have an idea. lets let the nation that did as much testing on its populace as the soviets and nazis unbridled control of healthcare and every other system. what could go wrong.

Accuse us of taking the most radical comments we could find (and its true that there was a lot of genuinely intelligent conversation), but the fact is that there are a lot of people who think this way.  They believe that they shouldn’t be burdened with helping other people.  That because they are healthy, pardon the language, screw everybody else.

The level of greed displayed in that thinking is absolutely amazing.  But it isn’t a small thing.  All over the conservative arena, there are people who will fight tooth and nail to get out the view that they shouldn’t have to help other people, because it’s their money.

Never mind that if universal health care was implemented, they would be saving money.  Never mind that such a system would save everybody money in the long term.  That’s too hard a thing to consider.  The fact is that they are being told, day in and day out that all of this help for the poor is funding laziness and everything else.  Not helping families who desperately need it.

There are plenty of people in America who are working two jobs and who don’t go to the doctor because they know that they can’t afford it.  This is not a new phenomenon.  But the machines of conservative America are putting out every day that these people are just leeches, hoping that the government will hold their hand.  Totally ignoring the fact that these people don’t want anybody to hold their hand.  They are busting tail and working hard to stay alive.  They merely want, and desperately need, help.  Help that should be given because we are supposed to be a better people than what we want to be.

But the greater existential question comes to this – why?  Why do these people just so adamently refuse to believe that this is for a good cause?  Perhaps the answer comes from the fact that nobody wants to sacrifice.  Make people believe that they are going to have to sacrifice, and they will simply work against it.  It is a fact that even in times of hardship, nobody wants to give up some of their good for the betterment of others.

An irony of that statement, however, is that the bulk of the people against universal health care in America identify themselves as Christian.  Being against this is kind of odd, in that respect, because if you look at their holy book, the Bible, there is a passage where Jesus Christ, their savior, openly says how people should treat the poor.

Luke 3:11 “If you have two coats,” he replied, “give one to the poor. If you have extra food, give it away to those who are hungry.”

Helping the poor was a core tenant of the son of the God that they believe is what America is based around, and yet whenever somebody talks about universal health care, there is an argument that often comes up that these people are leeches, and that they shouldn’t have to pay so that they can be lazy.

There was a brilliant quote by Stephen Colbert about how America treats the least of its people –

If this is going to be a Christian nation that doesn’t help the poor, either we have to pretend that Jesus is just as selfish as we are, or we’ve got to acknowledge that He commanded us to love the poor and serve without condition and then admit that we just don’t want to do it.

But these quotes haven’t answered the question – why?  Why do these people seem so dead-set against helping the people who are the most hurt by the current health care system?  Perhaps the ultimate answer is that they don’t know.  Just like so many other people in this country, it is just easier to go with the flow, and not to question something, than it is to step up and fight for anything.

If that is the case, then the real question becomes – what has America come to?

Peace out,

Lefty

Advertisements

Comments on: "America and Greed: A Health Care Story" (7)

  1. Reblogged this on Lucien Maverick's Blog and commented:

    My more intellectual thoughts on this subject.

  2. someguy said:

    The reason most Christians are against universal healthcare is NOT because it would help the less fortunate. Its because they dont support abortion/contraceptives. if Christians dont care about giving up thier time, talents and money for others, why are there Christian missionary groups in Mexico, Africa and Haiti? Or Christian food drives here in the states? the reason our healthcare is lacking compared to other countries could be attributed to alot of other things; not Christians. For example, other countries dont have 10 million people illegally coming into thier country for benfits. There is no “one cause” to this mess, but its certainly not the christians.

    • Lucien said:

      And yet they ignore the teachings of their savior. Convenient, no?

      • someguy said:

        The universal health care brings contraceptives that are against thier beliefs. You’re conveying that they should ignor a belief to uphold another. What they’re doing is upholding both beliefs by denieing the universal healthcare (because it promotes abortion) AND going out and helping the less fortunate (with thier TIME and MONEY which is them NOT being greedy). No teaching is being ignored. It’s not being upheld in the way you DONT* like. If you’re going to use the bible for a reference you can’t just pick the parts that agree with your concept.
        1 Chron. 25:5 – God exalts His people by blessing them with many children. When married couples contracept, they are declaring “not your will God, but my will be done.”

        They believe BOTH and they are upholding BOTH.

        *sorry typo

      • Lucien said:

        Yeah, I am advocating that they should ignore their outdated desert fairy-tale beliefs in favor of doing something right. And you are ignoring – Jesus advocated to help the poor, without EXCEPTION. You help them absolutely, and always. To not advocate for universal healthcare is against that. But again, we shouldn’t be appealing to desert fairytales, anyway. First Amendment helps us there.

  3. someguy said:

    The universal health care brings contraceptives that are against thier beliefs. You’re conveying that they should ignor a belief to uphold another. What they’re doing is upholding both beliefs by denieing the universal healthcare (because it promotes abortion) AND going out and helping the less fortunate (with thier TIME and MONEY which is them NOT being greedy). No teaching is being ignored. It’s not being upheld in the way you like. If you’re going to use the bible for a reference you can’t just pick the parts that agree with your concept.
    1 Chron. 25:5 – God exalts His people by blessing them with many children. When married couples contracept, they are declaring “not your will God, but my will be done.”

    They believe BOTH and they are upholding BOTH.

  4. someguy said:

    so what your saying is they should ignor thier beliefs? in the article they were called out for ignoring thier beliefs, it implys that christians should hold firm in thier beliefs about helping others. I proved that they do hold firm in that, but now your saying that they should give up thier religion? … yes i think your forgeting part of the first amendment:

    Congress shall make no law respecting an establishment of religion, OR PROHIBITING THE FREE EXCRCISE THEREOF…..

    this is peoples free excrcise of religion. Jesus did help the poor, without exception; also without contraception. he went out himself and helped the poor. One big problem with christians and universal healthcare is that it hinders the free excircise of thier religion. It will make religious orginizations (anything but a church) pay for contraception for thier employies. that is violating the first amendment. You cant just say ” well thier religion is a fairytale and shouldnt be listened to”. Thier freedom to religion is the FIRST amendment. there’s more historical evidence that Jesus existed than Cleopatra. But have you ever questioned that she did? Jesus is no fairytale.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

Tag Cloud

%d bloggers like this: